Paul’s Pizza Shop Menu and Prices updated 2021


Paul’s Pizza Shop Menu


You’ll Taste The Difference! We start with old-fashioned dough (made here daily), add our unique rich premium pizza sauce and then use whole-milk mozzarella cheese!

Paul’s Pizza Shop Menu and Prices


Garlic Cheese Bread $1.75
Buffalo Wings $6.99 – $10.99
extra hot, hot, medium and mild. Served with celery and bleu cheese dressing. Add 50¢ for: BBQ sauce,Minced garlic or Italian
Pizza Breadsticks $1.99
Cheese Sticks $4.99
Paul’s Pepperoni Rolls $3.95 – $5.95

Gourmet Salads and Soups

Salad Bar Ala Carte $5.99
To-Go Salad Bar $4.99
To-Go Salad Bar with 1-trip Salad Bar to pasta, sandwich or pizza order $3.99
To-Go Salad Bar with Breadsticks to any salad $5.99
Soup Ala Carte $2.99
Soup Ala Carte with 1-trip Soup to pasta, sandwich or pizza $4.48


flat thin spinach crust and flat thin whole-wheat crust avaliable
Cheese Pizza $5.99 – $9.99
Each Additional Topping $0.70 – $1.05
Masterpiece Special $8.99 – $15.99
Deep Dish $18.99
Chicago style, up to 4 toppings
Supreme, Veggie or Meat Lover $7.99 – $13.99
Calzone $6.99

Pizza by the Slice

Cheese $2.50
giant slice
Pepperoni $2.65
giant slice
Pizza Buffet Slice $1.00
small slice
Pizza Buffet $1.50
Desert Slice $1.50
small slice

Speciality Pizzas

Spinach Alfredo $13.99 – $9.99
creamy Alfredo sauce topped with artichokes, spinach and mushrooms
BBQ Chicken or Smoked Sausage $13.99 – $9.99
BBQ sauce, chicken or smoked sausage, red onions, bacon and cilantro
Santa Fe $13.99 – $9.99
chicken, corn, roasted black beans, red, yellow and green peppers, and sauteed onions
Margarita Pizza $13.99 – $9.99
diced marinated Roma tomatoes, fresh basil, feta cheese and mozzarella cheese
Desert Pizza $13.99 – $9.99
famous cheesecake sauce, topped with seasonal fruit


with chicken or meatballs add 1.50
Spaghetti with Sauce $4.99
Spaghetti with Meatballs $6.49
Alfredo Pasta $6.99
penne or spaghetti
Paul’s Spinach Pasta $5.99
Kid’s Spaghetti $3.99
With butter or marinara


Pizza Sub $5.95
Canadian bacon, pepperoni, tomatoes, mozzarella cheese and caesar dressing
Meatball Sub $5.95
meatballs, pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese
Ham $5.95
ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo, onions, banana peppers and oil dressing
Fajita Chicken $5.95
fajita chicken, provolone cheese, bell peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes and mayonnaise
Turkey $5.95
turkey, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo, onions, banana peppers and oil dressing
Italian Sub $5.95
ham, salami, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo, onions, banana peppers and oil dressing
Add Capicola $0.50
spicy Italian ham


Lunch Buffet $6.99
Dinner Buffet $8.99
Beverage with Buffet $0.99
Kids Buffet $4.99


Paul’s Famous Homemade Cheesecake $3.95
Ultimate Chocolate Cake $3.95
Kris’ Carrot Cake $3.95
Dessert Pizza $9.99 – $15.99


Soft Drinks $1.49
Ice Tea $1.49
Slushies $1.49
Soft Drinks, Ice Tea or Slushies with Buffet $0.99
Bottles $1.99
Kid’s Drink $0.99

* DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.





More menus are available on our website, which you are welcome to share with your friends. Keep an eye on our website for more menus.

Leave a Comment