New City Cafe Menu and Prices updated 2021


New City Cafe Menu

New City Café & Roastery welcomes you! We are ready to help you and are located in Rochester’s Beechwood area. We source high-quality coffee from across the world and collaborate with other local companies to create a unique community meeting area.
Our goal therefore pervades all we do, including coffee roasting. We acquire high-quality, fairly traded coffee from excellent producers and roast it with care to bring forth each bean’s unique taste.

Bags of coffee can be purchased in our café, online, or in bulk for your company, office, or church.

New City Cafe Menu and Prices

Egg Platters

served with potatoes
Two Eggs Any Style $2.50
Two Eggs Any Style $1.00
with bacon, ham, sausage or canadian bacon
Two Eggs Any Style $1.25
with homemade corned beef hash


all omelettes made with 2 eggs, served with potatoes and toast
Cheese $3.25
american or swiss
Western $3.25
onion, peppers, ham
Mushroom and cheese $3.25
Mediterranean $3.25
with swiss cheese and tomatoes
Greek $3.25
with feta cheese and tomatoes
Meat Lover $3.25
with bacon, ham, sausage or canadian bacon

Low Calorie Omelettes

all omelettes, platters or sandwiches are available in egg whites
Florentine Omelette $3.25
french spinach, tomato and feta cheese
California $3.25
mushrooms, tomatoes and low fat swiss or muenster cheese
Four Season $3.25
spinach, mushrooms, broccoli and fresh tomatoes

French Toast and Pancakes

Cinnamon Challah French Toast $2.75
French Toast $2.95
with bacon, ham or sausage
French Toast $2.95
with 2 fried eggs
Fluffy homemade buttermilk pancakes $2.75
Pancakes $3.25
with bacon, ham or sausage

Hot Oatmeal

Hot Oatmeal $2.25
served with fresh apples, raisins, granola, cinnamon or honey

Fresh Fruit Salad

Fresh Fruit Salad $2.25 – $2.95
seasonal fruits and melon with mixed berries

No Fat Yogurt Parfait

No Fat Yogurt Parfait $2.25 – $2.75
with fresh fruit, berries and crunchy granola

Freshly Baked Bagels

plain, onion, everything, poppy seed, sesame seed, cinnamon raisin, pumpernickel, whole wheat smoked cranberry, banana walnut, chocolate cream cheese
Cream Cheese $1.25
Scallion Cream Cheese $1.50
Lox Spread $1.95
Plain $0.75
with butter or jelly
Vegetable Cream Cheese $1.50
Scallion Cream Cheese $1.50
Lox Spread $1.95


Apple Oat Bran
High Fiber Bran
Apple Oat Bran
Triple Berry
Orange Sunflower

Specialty Sandwiches

new city signature sandwiches are created for you from a selection of fine meats, poultry, cheese and fresh garden vegetables and served on brick oven breads and rolls. Freshly made dressing compliment these flavorful combinations. Served with your choi
Fresh Roasted Turkey $5.95
with fresh spinach, honey mustard and plum tomatoes on country sourdough bread
Grilled Chicken Breast $5.95
on pompei sourdough bread with oven roasted red peppers, tomatoes, lettuce, honey mustard and finely julienne carrots
Fresh Carved Turkey $5.95
grilled canadian bacon, cranberry chutney, leaf lettuce, plum tomatoes on rustic country roll
Vegetarian, $5.95
tomatoes, cucumber, carrots, alfalfa sprouts, sundried tomatoes and hummus on hearth bread
Applewood Smoked Turkey Breast and Brie $5.95
with honey mustard, lettuce and tomato on crispy parisian baguette
Traditional Tuna Salad $5.95
albacore tuna tossed with mayonnaise and celery, topped with oven roasted peppers, tomatoes and leaf lettuce on a whole grain baguette
Danube $5.95
imported black forest ham, finlandia swiss cheese, greenleaf lettuce, vine ripered tomatoes and dijon mustard on russian black bread
Chicken Cutlet $5.95
fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, leaf lettuce, plum tomatoes with olive tapenade on semolina bread
Homemade Fresh Mozzarella $5.95
ripe plum tomatoes, oven roasted red peppers and leaf basil, drizzled with first run imported olive oli and butcher’s black papper on italian hearth bread
El Paso Chicken $5.95
roasted chicken breast delightfully mexican spiced, roasted red onions and peppers, leaf lettuce, plum tomatoes, pepperjack cheese and southwestern chipotle sauce on a puebla roll
Rare Roast Beef $5.95
caramelized onions, cheddar cheese, russian dressing on onion brioche
Italian Submarine $5.95
prosciutto, cappicola, genoa salami, shaved romano cheese oven roasted peppers, shaved onions and lettuce drizzled with cracked pepper vinaigrette on a semolina hero
City Cafe Hero $5.95
genoca salami, baked ham, cappicola ham, roast peppers, provolone cheese, olive oil and vinegar

Classic Sandwiches

Baked Turkey Breast $4.45
Smoked Turkey Breast $4.45
Roast Beef $4.45
Boiled Ham $4.45
Smoked Black Forest Ham $4.45
Honey Glazed Virginia Ham $4.45
Prosciutto Ham $4.45
Pastrami $4.45
Honey Glazed Turkey $4.45
Pepper Turkey $4.45
Liverwurst $4.45
Bologna $4.45
Genoa Salami $4.45
Ham and Cheese $4.45
Roast Beef
russian dressing, imported swiss and fresh spinach

Custom Wraps

Napa Valley $5.75
free range chicken marinated in rosemary and lemon, grilled and mixed with baby lettuce, ripe avocado, oven roasted peppers, tomatoes and a low fat ranch dressing served in a spinach wrap
Kyoto $5.75
charbroiled teriyaki marinated chicken and sauteed broccoli, stir-fry rice with oriental vegetables in a spinach wrap
Moroccan Chicken Wrap $5.75
grilled vegetables, cous cous, fresh spinach, almonds, raisins, caramelized onions in a spinach wrap
Grilled Chicken B.L.T. Wrap $5.75
crispy smoked bacon, leaf lettuce, plum tomato, lite mayonnaise on a spinach lavoush
Lite Italian Tuna Salad Wrap $5.75
a combination of freshest vegetables, layered with alfalfa sprouts and albacore tuna packed in water to create a tasty sensation, being lowfat (without mayonnaise) and delicious
Mediterranean Vegetable Wrap $5.75
fresh grilled seasonal vegetables, layered with alfalfa sprouts, avocado and melted tomatoes wrapped in a whole wheat tortilla spread with homemade hummus
Grilled Chicken Caesar $5.75
with crispy romaine, oven roasted red peppers, grated romano cheese, tomatoes and homemade caesar dressing in a caesar wrap
Grilled Chicken Pesto $5.75
fresh mozzarella, marinated sundried tomatoes and arugula on a spinach lavoush
Turkey Cobb Club Wrap $5.75
traditional combination of fresh turkey, ripe avocado, alfalfa sprouts, tomatoes and light blue cheese dressing in a spinach wrap
Bar-B-Que Chicken $5.75
leaf lettuce, southwestem cole slaw, shredded cheddar cheese in a sundried tomato wrap-served hot
Las Brisas, Our $5.75
traditional mexican chicken fajita having charbroil chicken, oven roasted spicy onions and red and green peppers mixed with salsa picante in a lemon cilantro tortilla-served hot

Flame-Kissed Burgers

all above accompanied by kosher dill pickle and cole slaw
Certified Angus Beef $3.50
Turkey $3.50
Garden $3.50
Lettuce and Tomato $0.50
French Fries $1.95
Crispy Bacon $1.00

City Deluxe Burger

City Deluxe Burger $5.25
served with french fries, lettuce, tomato and kosher dill pickle

Soups of the Day

Soups of the Day $2.25 – $2.75
hearty homemade soups, stews and chills. made fresh daily served with brick oven bread


hot grilled sandwiches on european flatbread
Smokey Turkey Melt $5.95
grilled vegetable ratatoujlle with melted swiss cheese and pesto mayo
Sierra Turkey $5.95
fresh roasted turkey with pepperjack cheese and southwestern chipotle sauce
Italian Club $5.95
turkey, ham, genoa salami, provolone cheese and red onion garlic aioli
Chicken Milano $5.95
charbrioled chicken breast with fresh mozzarella and pesto mayo
Cubano $5.95
roast pork tenderloin, fresh turkey, swiss cheese, dill pickle chips and russian dressing
Tuscan Melt $5.95
fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, fresh basil and pesto mayo
Tuna Melt $5.95
our albacore tuna salad with roasted red peppers crushed black pepper, oil and vinegar
San Pietro $5.95
prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers crushed black pepper, oil and vinegar
Kansas City $5.95
rare roast beef, dijon mustard and swiss cheese
Grilled Chicken Tijuana $5.95
mexican grilled chicken breast, chipotle bbq sauce, grilled peppers and onions with monterrey jack cheese
Baked Chicken Parmigiana $5.95
tender chicken cutlet, breaded and oven baked with fresh homemade marinara sauce and fresh mozzarella cheese
Baked Eggplant Parmigiana $5.95
oven roasted eggplant, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, marinara sauce and parmesan cheese
Chicken Romano $5.95
crispy breast of chicken, roasted italian plum tomatoes, topped with mushrooms and fresh mozzarella cheese

Signature Items from our Grill

NY famous Hot Corn Beef $5.45
pastrami or combo piled high on jewish rye bread with confetti cole slaw and kosher dill pickle
Reuben $6.45
prime roasted beef or fresh turkey served open face with sauerkraut and melted swiss on jewish rye
Philly Cheese Steak $5.45
prime roasted beef, grilled mushrooms, peppers onions and melted pepperjack cheese on a semolina hero
Grilled Chicken Deluxe $5.45
served on a toasted seeded bun with lettuce, tomatoes and our crispy french fries
Grilled Cheese $2.95
Grilled Cheese $3.95
with bacon or ham
Grilled Cheese $3.30
with tomato
Full House $4.25
grilled cheese with bacon or ham and tomato

New City Café Flip Salad

croutons.scallions. alfalfa sprouts
Fresh Roasted Turkey $1.00
Base Salads $2.75
crispy romaine
Base Salads $3.75
baby field greens
Sliced Mushrooms $0.50
Chick Peas $0.50
Broccoli Florets $0.50
Roasted Peppers $0.50
Beets $0.50
Sliced Red Onions $0.50
Sliced Peppers $0.50
Cherry Tomatoes $0.50
Diced Tomatoes $0.50
Green Peas $0.50
Shredded Carrots $0.50
Romano Cheese $0.50
Beans $0.50
Cucumbers $0.50
Sunflower Seeds $0.50
Roasted Corn $0.50
Chinese Noodles $0.50
Crumbled Blue Cheese $0.75
Feta Cheese $0.75
Crispy Bacon $0.75
Hard Cooked Eggs $0.75
Mandarin Oranges $0.75
Shredded Jack and Cheddar $0.75
Water Chestnuts $0.75
Toasted Almonds $0.75
Grilled Tofu $0.75
Grilled Asparagus $0.75
Black Olives $0.75
Artichoke Hearts $0.75
Handmade Mozzarella $1.00
Portobello Mushrooms $1.00
Fresh Roasted Turkey $1.00
Albacore Tuna $1.00
Grilled Chicken $1.00
Sun Dried Tomatoes $1.00
Crispy Chicken $1.00
Fresh Ripe Avocado $1.00
Thai Chicken $1.00

Freshly Made Entr?e Salads

our best seller
Gotham Chopped Salad $4.95
chicken breast, smoked country ham, hard cooked eggs, tomatoes, crispy bacon, swiss cheese, iceberg lettuce and thousand island dressing
Caesar Salad $4.95
hearts of romaine, shaved romano cheese and homemade croutons
Grilled Chicken Over Caesar $4.95
grilled breast of chicken over crisp refreshing caesar salad
Cobb Salad $4.95
oven roasted turkey, rows of perfect avocado, sprouts, sliced mushrooms and sliced tomatoes over house salad
Greek Salad $4.95
feta cheese, stuffed grape leaves, cherry tomatoes, red onions, kalamata olives on a bed of mixed greens
Southwestern Chicken $4.95
slow roasted cajun chicken, santa fe coin salad, garnished over baby organic greens
House Garden Salad $2.75 – $4.50
crisp leaf lettuce, radicchio, watercress, romaine, shredded carrots, cherry tomatoes, garni
Oriental Chicken Salad $4.95
tender chicken in light ginger sesame dressing with chinese noodles, oriental vegetables and water chestnuts over house salad low fat
Chef Salad $4.95
prime roast beef, fresh roasted turkey, swiss and american cheese, hard cooked eggs, cherry tomatoes, garni on a bed of mixed greens

Pizza by the Slice

Plain or Margherita $1.75 – $2.50
Margherita $12.50 – $5.95
fresh tomato sauce, fresh basil, fresh mozzarella, parmigiana cheese (the perfect pizza)
Verona $15.95 – $7.95
grilled chicken, fresh tomato sauce, diced fresh tomatoes, fresh mozzarella cheese and red and green bell peppers
Napolitana $14.95 – $6.95
fresh tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, spinach, button mushrooms and tomatoes
Garden Vegetali $15.95 – $6.95
yellow squash, zucchini, broccoli, mushrooms, tomatoes, carrots, eggplant, mozzarella and vine ripened tomato sauce
Southwestern $15.95 – $7.95
bar-b-que chicken, crispy smoked bacon, roasted peppers and onions with mozzarella and tomato sauce
Mediterrano $15.95 – $6.95
spicy italian salami, roasted tomato sauce, mozzarella and caramelized onions
Cinque $15.95 – $7.95
crispy chicken cutlet, fresh diced tomatoes and mozzarella cheese
Napoli $14.95 – $6.95
arrabiata sauce, italian sausage, roasted peppers, mozzarella cheese, parmigiana sauce

Our Suggestions

18 pie
Pepperoni and Roasted Peppers $15.95
Mushroom and Onions $14.95
Fresh Tomato and Spinach $14.95
Chicken and Broccoli $14.95

Create your own Pizza

comes with variety toppings: italian sausage, pepperoni, grilled chicken chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, bar-b-que chicken, roasted onions or peppers, black olives, peppers, fresh plum tomatoes, spinach, braccoli, grilled vegetables, mushrooms, extra ch
Pizza $12.95 – $5.95

From the Pizza Baker

Chicken Roll $3.95
Sausage Roll $3.95
Vegetable Roll $3.95
Cheese Calzone $3.50
Sausage Calzone $3.95
Stuff Pizza $3.95
Garlic Knots $1.00

Chef’s Table Entrees

mix and match
Pasta, Roasted Vegetables or Sumptuous Sides $5.95
any three
Chicken Entr?e $5.95
with two sides
Beef Entr?e $5.95
with two sides
Fish Entr?e $5.95
with two sides
Side Order of any Pasta or Sumptuous Side $3.95
Side Order of Mashed Potato or Rice $3.00

Coffee Bar

Coffee or Decaffeinated Coffee $0.65 – $1.25
Tea $0.65 – $1.25
Herbal Tea $0.75 – $1.50
Hot Chocolate $0.65 – $1.25
Espresso $1.50 – $2.00
Cappuccino $2.00 – $2.50
Moccachino $2.25 – $2.75
Café Latte $1.25 – $2.25
Iced Coffee $1.25
Iced Cappuccino $2.50
Iced Moccachino $2.75
Bottled Water $1.00 – $2.25
Canned Soda $1.00
Snapple $1.45

New City Café Bagels

Plain $0.65
Plain $0.65
Plain $0.75
with butter or jelly
Vegetable Cream Cheese $1.50
Plain $0.65
Cream Cheese and Jelly $1.50
Smoked Salmon and Cream Cheese $3.95


real whole fruit blended with low fat milk and non-fat yogurt to make a refreshing nutritional drink
Sunset Orange $3.95
banana and orange
Tropical Tango $3.95
fresh strawberries and banana
Aloha Berry $3.95
golden pineapple and strawberries
Triple Berry $3.95
cranberries, strawberries and raspberries
Mocha Espresso $3.95
espresso and imported chocolate

Homemade Desserts

N.Y. Cheese Cake $3.25
Rice Pudding or Chocolate Pudding $2.50
Fruit Jello $1.95
Chocolate, Block and White or Raspberry Mousse $2.75
Assorted Homemade $2.95
luscious layer cakes

* DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.


More menus are available on our website, which you are welcome to share with your friends. Keep an eye on our website for more menus.

Leave a Comment